A Discussion of What Home Means We’re like turtles, who carry their homes on their backs. Our home Is a movable feast; we can recreate wherever we gather. ?Kathy Thurber, Humanities and English Instructor, West Virginia university What Is the definition of home? What does home mean to other people? Does home necessarily a safe and cozy place? What brings you security when you are at home? Can home be anywhere? In recent discussions of “what Is home” In the book Socrates should be a personal or social notion.
On the one hand, some argue that home Is a residential place where people feel safe and relax. From a personal perspective, people see home as a residential place where they can feel safe and relax. On the other hand, however, others argue that home should be a social place that belongs to everyone in the society. In other words, home is the beginning of societies and nation states: nation states and societies give people a great sense of belonging. According to this definition, home is not only a place where people originally come from, but also is the root of their race, ethnicity, culture and citizenship.
The relationship between personal home and social home is inseparable. The existence of personal homes is dependent on a well society. On the other hand, a well society is formed by groups of good personal homes. In fact, nation states are derived from societies, and societies are originated from personal homes. From my point of view, I believe that home should be both personal and social. Though I concede that the concept of home is more a personal place, I still agree that home plays an important role in society.
For example, if someone owns a home hysterically but he doesn’t accept his society or country, the place where the home is physically located may not be a real home to him. Some may object that even though they come from the country where they were originated, they never consider that place their home for other reasons. However, I think that their “homeland” should be the society where they believe their identity and spirituality belong to. The Issue is Important because everyone should have at least one home – a home where you can be your true self and where you believe you belong to.
Home Is not limited too hysterical house one lives, but it can be the country one belongs. Even a “homeless” person can have a home because they belong to their country. In this case, personal homes and social homes can co-exalts at the same time. Social homes cannot be formed without a strong bond of personal homes. And personal homes cannot be formed without a stable society. Hence, we can see the subtle relationship between personal and social home. Home, regardless It’s personal or social, Is a place where you believe that you belong to.
When it comes to the definition of what is home, most of us will readily agree that mom Is a personal Issue Tanat Is related to ourselves Ana our Tamely. Some may Attlee home as a physical structure where you live. One of the participants in the Socrates Cafe claims that “home is where your bed is” (Phillips 56). According to this view, home is a place where you can sleep and get refresh after a day of work. The “home” here is a physical definition. According to Thro, who wrote one of the comments on the discussion bolo of West Virginia University, he agrees with this point. Home, to me, is where I sleep and find a relative amount of security for my personal possessions. Vive moved around in my life, and every place regardless of geographical location feels like home to me” (“What Is Home? “). To him, home can be anywhere he lives. However, many people disagree with his view that home is Just a residential dwelling. They believe that a “physical home” is Just a house, but not a real home. Instead, home should be a place where someone has some sort of emotional and sentimental attachment.
The emotional attachment of home is an essential element of forming a strong tie of personal home in a society. Connotatively, many people believe that home is a place where you feel safe and be Ovid. According to one of the participants in the Socrates Cafe©, “home is a place, a special place, where we each in certain sense reside. For many of us this place can be nice and comforting, for others it can be rather awful and discomforting. But all instance it’s still home” (Phillips 60). Basically, she is saying that home is a special place where people can find peace and relaxation.
I agree that home should be a place where you can feel nice and comfortable because it makes the physical place you live more curable and relaxing, so that it will be more desirable to live in. In there words, to make it more home. Besides, she also insists on that home is actually a place where you possess. Home is your own place where it offers security and happiness, and you can have the freedom to do whatever you like. On the discussion bolo of West Virginia University, one of the comments written by Clare, explained this idea felicitously. [Home] is a place where you can really be fully yourself and a place where you can get unconditional affection” (“What Is Home? “). Home is a place which does not belong to anyone else. The sense of belonging and security is an important impotent of making a good personal and social home. Moreover, your home is not bound by limitations. Sarah Goode, one of the participants who wrote comment on the discussion bolo, explains that “[home is] the place(s) you feel the most comfortable. There could be only one, and there could be more.
What matters is that they are the places that you have your best times and your happiest memories” (“What Is Home? “). As long as we feel comfortable and confident with that environment, and we can truly be ourselves, that place or situation can possibly be our home. You can be at home when you are traveling; you an be at home when you are at school, at work, or at anywhere you feel the most comfortable. In the Socrates Cafe©, a freelance Journalist shows us how home can be conceptual idea without a physical structure. “Sometimes I think the only time I feel at home is when I’m on the road.
To this day, after I’m home for more than a week, I start to get antsy. I pull out the atlas and look at all the places Vive been and all the places I’d still want to go’ (Phillips 57). From his experience, we can see that traveling around gives NV ten most comfort. 10 nil, to road Is Nils none. It proves Tanat none an be anywhere as long as it makes the most comfortable living. To many people, home is a place where the presence of their family. According to the discussion in the Socrates Cafe©, one of the participant states that “my home was my family. My home was the people I loved most” (Phillips 61).
In other words, he believes that his family is the pillar of his home. I agree with him because in my own experience, family members play an important role in a home. A home with family members doesn’t mean that a home cannot be “anywhere. ” According to this point of view, home is where your family members are. It can be anywhere in the world as long as we are together with our family. We can feel like home even if we are in a hotel room, in an apartment overseas, or on a Journey in a car. A home with family often implies that it’s a home with treasonable memories and unconditional affection, no matter sad or happy.
As if the discussion in Socrates Cafe© states that “[home] is a special place I care about more than any others” (Phillips 59). Because of the subtle bond you have with your family, we care about our family members. By losing our family members, we lose our treasonable memories. Therefore, the presence of Emily make our home complete. This explains no matter how frequently people move from one place to another, “whatever place [they] lived in as a home and not just a house” (Phillips 57). It is a place where they can line with their family.
As Kathy Thurber wrote in the quote at the beginning of the essay, she thinks that her family is like a turtle, which moves its home with its body to anyplace in the world. To her, she believes that home can be recreated wherever your family members gather. She cares about her family more than any others. It makes her feel home when she is with her family. She believes that no matter how their family is geographically separated, they still can recreate a true home wherever they reunite again. We can see that family has a crucial linkage with the concept of a true home.
Although I agree that family is an important ingredient in making a real home, I cannot completely accept the overall conclusion that a home is Just a place where your family members are. A personal home can be formed without a family. A personal home without family is another essential element of social home. Some may argue that not everybody has a full family or they don’t even have a family. Referring to the Socrates Cafe©, one of the participants says “l was raised in an orphanage. It wasn’t a pleasant experience, and I never consider it home.
After I left the orphanage, I lived by myself and relied only on myself” (Phillips 61). He points out that there is no such thing as family in his experience. For those who don’t have a family, can they still belong to a place called home? This man comes up with an answer. “l am my home” (Phillips 61). He believes his soul is his home. It is his body that he wants to rely on. In other words, home is not necessarily a place with a family. That is, a person can move away from his or her family and start a new home in a new place. Whether the new place is considered as home depends on how the person feels about the new place.
If you can be fully yourself, home can be any place with or without your family. Having Just argued that home is a personal place where people physically and sentimentally reside; let us now turn our attention to the social role of home. On a macro scale, none can De talent as a collects, a Anton state, or an ethnicity According to the Socrates Cafe©, Phillips elaborates the concept of home of George Webber. For Webber, “home is where the place you come from” (Phillips 58). Webber believes that home is “a valued place regarded as the place of origin” (“Home”). In order words, home is the birth place of all people.
The concept of roots is commonly based on a nation state and a nationality. A social home creates a society, and societies create a nation state. The word “homeland” basically means one’s native land. It is a “state, region, or territory that is closely identified with a particular people or ethnic group” (“Homeland”). In the Socrates Cafe©, one of the participants elaborates this concept based on an example of Socrates. For Socrates, home was all of Athens. And that’s one reason why, when the tribunal who prosecuted him gave him a choice of being exiled from Athens instead of being put to death, he refused.
Because to go out from Athens would’ve made him feel homeless. He preferred death to homeless. (61) To Socrates, Athens is his home. A home can be a nation when we admit to the nation and consider that nation as our motherland. A nation state offers people an identity and nationality. If Socrates had gone out from Athens, he would have lost his identity and nationality which would have made him feel homeless. Indeed, home is the nation where you originally come from. Does your native land necessarily be your home? Here many immigrants would probably object this notion.
There are many people move away from their home country because of war, political issues, economics crisis and law. According to another participant in the Socrates Cafe©, she shows us how her roots are not a home for her. Was born and raised in Germany. It was my homeland, but it is in no way a home to me. ‘ [Phillips] relates that she and her family had to leave Germany to escape the horrific Nazi persecution of the Jews. Germany in no sense is or was my home” (Phillips 60). She states that although Germany is where her roots are, it does not necessarily be her home because the country has forbidden her.
The government of her home country tried to eliminate her race in the country. In this case, her social home may not be her native land, but I think she still has a social home that can give her security and comfort. That is, she should have a society that gives her a sense of belonging. Especially in America, the most multicultural country in the world, thousands of immigrants move into America to “plant their roots” every year. Although they are not native to this land, they can still define themselves as Americans because they found themselves fitting into this society.
In many cases, “home is the place where you feel protected and secure, and where you know that you ‘belong’ without having to question it” (“What Is Home”). Once you believe that you belong to one society, you realize your identity, and where your social home is. The social environment in America provides people the sense of freedom and security. They build their personal home here because of the ideal social environment. When the cycle continues, more and more personal homes are armed, and communities are developed. After all, the society gives people the sense of belonging and the concept of social home becomes mature.
A social home is important because it brings something more than a personal home to everyone in the world. Although a personal home may bring us a certain level of personal secure TTY, It Is a social none Tanat actually rolling us spiritual peace Ana quietude. Socrates understands the importance of having an identity. He prefers death to losing his identity. A person who has no roots – who is not sure about his identity – always suffers from inner disturbance. As the writer of the book Catfish and Mandela, Andrew Pam was lost because he wasn’t clear what his identity is.
He had a hard time figuring out his true identity. He is a Vietnamese-American who moved to America when he was nine years old. He was born in Vietnam but raised in America. He considered himself as an American but others denied his identity. When he went back to Vietnam to search for his roots, people didn’t recognize him as a Vietnamese. “In America, I was a Jape [Japanese], a Chain [Chinese], a kook [Korean]; in Vietnam, a Russian” (Pam 244). He was frustrated about his identity. After his long Journey, he finally found his identity as an American, and America is his home even though he was born in Vietnam.
What he would do after he went home was to “be a better American” (Pam 341). In the very last sentence of his book, he had a conversation with a man on the plane. “This is America? ” the man asked. He replied miss, Brother, Welcome home” (Pam 342). He believes that he belongs to this society, he possesses “all [his] sweetest memories of America” (Pam 342). To him, America is his social home, the home that he believes his identity and soul belongs to. Once he loves this entry, he will develop his own personal home on this land. Therefore, we can see how a social environment is indeed an indivisible ingredient of making a personal home.
From all the arguments above, we learn that home can be one’s family and one’s country. As Meniscus, the great ancient Chinese Philosopher, says, the concept of home actually implies an interdependent relationship of individuals, family, states, and the foundation of human society (“Meniscus”). In other words, personal home creates societies and nation states, and society and nation state creates a social home. Meniscus elaborates this idea in the book Lila Part II. People have this common saying, ‘The kingdom, the State, the family. ‘ The root of the kingdom is in the State.
The root of the State is in the family. The root of the family is in the person [at] its head” (“The Works of Meniscus”). He stresses on the indivisible relationship between personal home and social home. An ideal country is an ideal place for people to build their own home. And an ideal home is built by people who believe the society is an ideal environment for them to “plant their roots. ” As a community grows, families are developed and the trend goes on. Eventually, a true home – a action state – is formed, a home that consists of a variety of societies and families.
When a nation state is built, the sense of belonging and identity is developed, the concept of social home becomes mature. Therefore, when the cycle persists in a positive way, a group of strong personal home will definitely become a concrete foundation of a harmonious nation state. To conclude, we can see the inseparable relationship between a personal home and a social home. A personal home is a “dwelling place together with the family or social unit that occupies it” (“Home”). It allows people to feel secure, comfortable, and free.
A social none Is a concept Witt regard to one’s ala TTY Ana naturally. It can De a geographical place where individuals maintain their memories, friends, and love. Both personal and social home share a common characteristic – it is a place where you believe you belong to. If people do not feel like belonging to a particular society, they can hardly develop a personal home there. If people do not like the personal home that they are living in, they won’t even call that place “a home”. In contrast, if people are homeless in terms of personal home, they can still feel like home in the country they like.